Ecommerce Academy · Chapter 07

Reviews on other sites

2 min read · · CiteCue Team

The reviews on your own product pages aren't the only ones an assistant reads. OpenAI says ChatGPT's review summaries are based on reviews from public websites, and Google says the ratings on its shopping listings come from merchants, review aggregators, review sites and Google users. A review site that ranks for your store's name, or a marketplace where you also sell, can shape an answer as much as your own pages.

Find the sites that matter

Which sites count differs by category, so check rather than guess. Ask two or three assistants a handful of buying questions, such as "is [store] legit?", "[product] reviews" and "best [category] under $100", and list every review site and marketplace they cite. For each, note the rating, the review count and the date of the newest review.

It helps to separate two kinds of review:

Kind Usually found on Answers
Product reviews Your product pages, marketplaces, review aggregators Is this item any good?
Store reviews Independent review sites, Google's store ratings Is this shop reliable?

Google's store ratings draw on its Google Customer Reviews program, independent review partners and Google's own research, and are calculated separately for each country. A store selling in two countries has two ratings to build. Marketplace listings get their own lesson, marketplaces as sources.

Build them honestly

Use the same request you send for reviews on your own site: every buyer, after delivery, nothing riding on the rating. Collect reviews honestly has the rules. If you pay a review platform to collect reviews for you, the FTC's guide for marketers says to make sure it clearly discloses that commercial relationship. The same guide warns against comparison sites that sell better rankings, and against using a platform's flagging tools to get honest negative reviews taken down.

Keep each platform's reviews on that platform. Google's review snippet guidelines say don't aggregate reviews or ratings from other websites in your own markup, and pasting them onto your pages invites a gap between what you claim and what the source shows.

Fix facts, not opinions

When a review site lists an old price, a former returns address or a discontinued product, ask it to correct the fact. Don't ask it to remove a fair negative review.

This week

Run three buying questions in two assistants and list the review sites they cite. For the top two, compare the rating, count and newest review date with your own site's. Pick the one where you're weakest and add it, as an option, to the request every buyer receives after delivery.

Sources

See where AI cites you, and where it doesn’t